If you can dream it,
I can
bake it.

Custom Cakes image
Prices starting at $45 (delivery fee included)

Everyone loves cake. That is a FACT.

This is why I offer perfectly tailored specialty cakes for birthdays, baby showers, graduations, office parties, holidays, and any other life event. Every cake is baked with high quality ingredients, and unlike other bakeries, creations from That Cake Lady both look good and taste great, and every piece is hand-crafted to suit your needs. Stun your party guests with amazing cake creations, or show someone you love how much you care with a thoughtful design. From simple desserts to complex creatures, no matter what type of cake you're looking for, I am passionate about helping you celebrate your next special occasion.

To order a custom cake: please review the questions listed below and submit them one of two ways:
If you'd like to order online, please copy and paste these questions into an email, answer them, and send it to thatcakeladysf@gmail.com.
If you'd like to order by phone, please call 505-303-0686.

What occasion are you shopping for?
How many people do you need to feed?
What shape/style of cake were you interested in?

Options: Sheet Cake (rectangle), Round Cake, Tiered Cake, Cupcakes, 
Cupcake Cake/Bouquet, Specialty Shape (please specify)
What flavors of cake were you interested in?
Would you like any fillings or add-ins?
What type of frosting would you like?

Options: vanilla buttercream, cream cheese icing, whipped cream, specialty flavored buttercream (please specify), specialty icing (please specify)
Do you have a design, theme, or colors in mind?
Do you have any pictures of what you would like (please attach them to the email)
What would you like written on the cake?
Please include any other information you would like me to know:
What day and time will you need this cake?
Please provide the delivery address:
What is your name, phone number, and email?


*Please note: filling out the above questions and submitting them via email or phone is NOT a guarantee of your order. Your order is NOT finalized until you a) receive a confirmation email from That Cake Lady confirming your order details and clarifying any issues and b) pay your deposit fee.

**Please note: all custom cakes require a 50% deposit once your order has been submitted and subsequently confirmed via email. Deposits can be paid by cash or credit card if you have an in-person consultation, but must be paid via credit/debit card over the phone if ordering a cake online or via phone. This deposit is non-refundable and non-transferable.


Prices starting at $100 (delivery fee not included)

Every wedding presents a unique and special opportunity to reflect your personal style in a beautiful and delicious way; with cake! When your family and friends gather to celebrate your big day, one thing everyone looks forward to is serving the wedding cake. Make that moment even more memorable with a completely custom cake from That Cake Lady of Santa Fe. From modern, chic sugar art to gorgeous bouquets to classic vintage piping, I can create a beautiful piece for any wedding occasion to best suit your needs.

Not entirely sure what you're looking for yet? No worries! I'm pleased to offer clients a personalized wedding cake consultation, complete with tastings and design samples. Please go to my 'Wedding Cake Consultations' page to learn more.

To order a wedding cake, please review the questions below and submit them one of two ways:
To order online, copy and paste these questions into an email, answer them, and send it thatcakeladysf@gmail.com.
To order over the phone, review the questions below and call 505-303-0686.
For all wedding cake orders, a follow-up consultation either in person or video chat is required.

Please provide the name of the bride and groom:
What is the theme and color scheme of your wedding?
How many people do you need to feed?
Will there be other desserts served at the reception?
What shape/style of cake were you interested in?

Options: Sheet Cake (rectangle), Round Cake, Tiered Cake, Cupcakes, Specialty Shape (please specify)
What flavors of cake were you interested in?
Would you like any fillings or add-ins?
Would you like the cake to be covered in fondant or frosting?
If frosting, what type of frosting would you like?

Options: vanilla buttercream, cream cheese icing, whipped cream, specialty flavored buttercream (please specify), specialty icing (please specify)
Do you have a specific design, theme, decoration, or colors already in mind?
Do you have any pictures of what you would like (please attach them to the email)
Would you like any writing or messages on the cake?
Please include any other information you would like me to know:
What day and time will you need this cake?

Note: wedding cakes require at least two weeks advance notice, if not longer
Please provide the delivery address:
What is your name, phone number, and email?
When are you available to meet in person or video chat to discuss the design of your cake?

*Please note: filling out the above questions and submitting them via email or phone is NOT a guarantee of your order. Your order is NOT finalized until you a) receive a confirmation email from That Cake Lady confirming your order details and clarifying any issues and b) pay your deposit fee.

**Please note: all custom wedding cakes require a 50% deposit once your order has been submitted and subsequently confirmed via email. Deposits can be paid by cash or credit card if you have an in-person consultation, but must be paid via credit/debit card over the phone if ordering a cake online or over the phone. This deposit is non-refundable and non-transferable.
Wedding Cakes image
Prices starting at $25 (delivery fee not included)

Satisfy your cravings today with a batch of custom baked goods and confections from That Cake Lady of Santa Fe! Whether you're looking for a unique dessert from around the world or a down-home classic you've always wanted to try, I am able to make anything you wish and deliver it straight to your home, business, or event.

I'd love to make your next party special with beautifully decorated sugar cookies, or please your guests with a decadent dessert trifle. You can surprise someone you love with a delivery of fresh-baked cookies or indulge yourself with a tin of old-fashioned fudge. I'm also pleased to offer an array of breads, rolls, and savory pastries to serve every kind of pallet. No matter what baked good, pastry, or confection you're in need of, if you can dream it, I can bake it!

To place an order for baked goods, please review the questions below and submit them one of two ways:
To order online, copy and paste these questions into an email and send them to thatcakeladysf@gmail.com
To order by phone, please review the questions and call 505-303-0686

What occasion are you shopping for?
How many people do you need to feed?
What type of baked good were you interested in?
What flavor were you interested in?
Would you like any fillings or add-ins?
Were you looking to have this item(s) decorated?
If so, do you have a design, theme, or colors in mind?
Do you have any pictures of what you would like (please attach them to the email)

Is this order for you or is it a gift? (gift options available)
Please include any other information you would like me to know:
What day and time will you need this order?
Please provide the delivery address:
What is your name, phone number, and email?


*Please note: filling out the above questions and submitting them via email is NOT a guarantee of your order. Your order is NOT finalized until you a) receive a confirmation email from That Cake Lady confirming your order details and clarifying any issues and b) pay your deposit fee.

**Please note: all baked good orders require a 50% deposit once your order has been submitted and subsequently confirmed via email. Deposits can be paid by cash or credit card if you have an in-person consultation, but must be paid via credit/debit card over the phone if ordering online or via phone. This deposit is non-refundable and non-transferable. The remaining balance for your order must be paid in full prior to delivery.

Baked Goods image

Event Catering

High-quality dessert and pastry services for any occasion and budget. Prices starting at $150

Learn More

Party Classes

Captivate guests of any age at your next party, sleepover, or bridal shower with a custom cake class! I deliver a fun, hassle-free, no-mess experience that your guests are sure to remember and cherish. Prices starting at $100

Learn More

Private Cake Decorating and Baking Lessons

Always wanted to make cakes yourself, but never knew where to start? I offer custom lessons in confectionery arts to meet your individual needs, and can help you succeed today. Prices start at $75

Learn More
Prices starting at $30 (delivery fee included)

Is your big day fast approaching and you're still unsure of what type of cake you'd like to order? Then you need to stop stressing and call That Cake Lady of Santa Fe for a Wedding Cake Consultation today! While other bakeries may offer a small and quick sampling of a few popular flavors, when you book an appointment with That Cake Lady, you don't get just another errand: you get a completely custom and personalized wedding experience.

All packages include a sampling of cake flavors, frostings, and fillings, as well as a guided design walk-through that will give you the confidence to choose every aspect of what you want your wedding cake to look like. I also offer a larger variety of customizable experience packages, including those with more cake varieties, flavors, and add-ins, as well as sampling other desserts you may want to incorporate into your reception. You can even request a decorating sample to be made with the designs you had in mind to be brought to your appointment so you can truly visualize your custom cake. You also have the option of sharing this special experience with family or friends when you purchase a multi-client consultation experience, even creating a cake-tasting party. This experience is also entirely mobile, so I am able to serve you in your home, at your event space, or at a rented meeting space.

Whether your wedding is a large affair or a smaller get-together, I always recommend booking a consultation to ensure you are satisfied with every flavor choice, decoration, and detail. No matter what you end up choosing, every client who books a consultation and places a cake order will receive a unique and beautiful cake design that will encapsulate your personal aesthetic and wedding decor.

Interested in booking your Wedding Cake Consultation experience? I can't wait to meet you! Please review the questions below so you can start to have an idea of what you may want, and please be encouraged to find different pictures online of the ideas you have or cakes you like and bring them to your appointment. Also be sure to go online and find any flavor combinations or edible decor you'd like to try and mention them when booking so I can create a truly custom experience to meet your needs.

To book an appointment, please email thatcakeladysf@gmail.com or call 505-303-0686.

Please provide the name of the bride and groom:
What is the theme and color scheme of your wedding?
How many people do you need to feed?
Will there be other desserts served at the reception?
What shape/style of cake were you interested in?

Options: Sheet Cake (rectangle), Round Cake, Tiered Cake, Cupcakes, Specialty Shape (please specifiy)
What flavors of cake were you interested in?
Would you like any fillings or add-ins?
Would you like the cake to be covered in fondant or frosting?
If frosting, what type of frosting would you like?

Options: vanilla buttercream, cream cheese icing, whipped cream, specialty flavored buttercream (please specify), specialty icing (please specify)
Do you have a specific design, theme, decoration, or colors already in mind?
Do you have any pictures of what you would like?

Would you like any writing or messages on the cake?
Please include any other information you would like me to know:
What day and time will you need this cake?

* wedding cakes require at least one week advance notice
Please provide the delivery address:
What is your name, phone number, and email?


*Please note: the fee for all appointments will be determined based upon the number of clients in your party, the number and type of cakes, fillings, frostings, and decorations you'd like to sample, the decorations you'd like to see models of, and where the appointment will take place. 

**Please note: all custom wedding cakes require a 50% deposit once your order has been submitted and subsequently confirmed via email. Deposits can be paid by cash or credit card if you have an in-person consultation, but must be paid via credit/debit card over the phone if ordering a cake online or over the phone. This deposit is non-refundable and non-transferable.
Wedding Cake Consultation image
  • Santa Fe, New Mexico, United States
About image
That Cake Lady of Santa Fe began in January of 2017 when I decided to turn my dream of professional baking and decorating into a reality. My name is Samantha Haynes, and I am the owner and cake artist behind TCLSF.

Born and raised in Santa Fe, I first started baking cakes in my teens after having spent years with my eyes glued to the television  watching the likes of Ace of Cakes, Challenge, Cupcake Wars, and of course The Cake Boss. To my surprise, it wasn't as easy as it looked. My earliest cakes were an ugly mess to say the least (though I've burned the pictures so no one can prove it). Beginning in the summer of 2014 I decided to enroll in the Wilton Method of Cake Decorating classes that were being held at my local craft store. The series of weekly courses took participants from the basics of buttercream to the advanced art of fondants and gum-paste flowers. To my utter surprise and no doubt by the grace of God, my teacher and I found that I actually had a knack for cake decorating after all! I graduated from those courses in 2015 with my certification as a Wilton Method decorator and have continued to gain many new skills since then, learning from some of the best resources in the industry. While cake competitions in our area are limited, I was grateful to take home the Blue Ribbon and win the title of Best in Show for the cake contests held at the Santa Fe County Fair in 2017.

I pursued cakes purely as a hobby for two years, but after working at odd jobs for years after high school I felt called to do something more with the skills I had been blessed with. What better way to do that than give back to the community what I had received! I enrolled with the Wilton Company as a Cake Decorating Instructor and completed their training and certification program in January of 2017, the same time I decided to start TCLSF. I launched my business from home and became the only cake decorating instructor in the area offering public and private cake classes, mainly through the Hobby Lobby teaching program.

Shortly after starting TCLSF I was offered a position at the Sam's Club bakery and remained with the Walmart Corporation as a cake decorator for thee years. I continued to manage TCLSF as well until moving out of state in August of 2018, when I made the tough decision to close down my business until I could give my clients the attention and time they deserved. That time finally came when I moved back to Santa Fe in the fall of 2019, and re-launched TCLSF in April of 2020 with more services, more experience, and more options than every before.

I continue to run the business from my home kitchen, and am passionate about serving the community with high-quality and beautiful cake creations for all of life's special moments. I am available for a wide variety of cake and baking related services, though I specialize in custom event cakes. I first earned my NM State Food Handler's Certification in 2014, and have maintained an active certification through 2023.

I truly consider it an honor and a blessing to do something I love and be a part of my client's special moments, and want nothing more than to meet your needs and turn your dreams into a reality. Thank you so much for taking the time to invest in a local operation, and I pray that I can use my skills and resources to serve you and our community to the best of my ability.

"Each of you should use whatever gift you have received to serve others, as faithful stewards of God's grace in it's various forms." 1 Peter 4:10, NIV


Do you offer delivery or pick up options? What are your fees?

I currently offer delivery for all cakes and baked goods, but do not offer pick up options. For all deliveries, I charge a small fee based upon how many miles are traveled and how many items are being delivered. This means the cost will vary from order to order and client to client.

Where is That Cake Lady of Santa Fe located?

I currently run my bakery out of my home kitchen in Santa Fe county. I serve clients in Santa Fe county and the surrounding areas with deliveries, in-home lessons and services, and public meeting space consultations. I am a NM Certified Food Handler and meet all safety and food preparation regulations.

Exactly what services do you offer?

That Cake Lady of Santa Fe exists to meet every one of your sugar needs! I offer custom cakes for special occasions, as well as quality custom baked goods. I design and execute wedding cakes and offer curated wedding cake consultation experiences. I now offer party entertainment packages, wherein I teach your party guests how to decorate a cake project. I also serve as an instructor of baking and cake decorating to individual clients for private in-home lessons. Lastly, I am available for event catering (desserts/pastries only).

What kind of cakes or pastries do you make? Is there a menu I can order from?

Here at That Cake Lady of Santa Fe, I specialize in completely custom cakes and baked goods. This means that the menu is whatever you can dream of! Whether it is a specialty flavor, an international dessert, a unique filling, design, or pastry, I can make it for you and deliver it right to your door. For cakes, I specialize in decorated cakes for special occasions and can create simple dessert cakes or masterfully sculpted pieces of art. If you can dream it, I can bake it!

How did That Cake Lady of Santa Fe begin?

That Cake Lady of Santa Fe was born out of a desire to serve others in my community with high-quality and beautiful cake creations to help them celebrate all of life's most wonderful moments. I truly enjoy using the gifts God has given me to make other people's day a little more special. I am blessed to have been able to do so since 2017.

How can I place an order?

Orders can be placed either by emailing thatcakeladysf@gmail.com or by calling 505-303-0686. Please visit the specific page for what you are looking to order right here on my website and review the order form questions prior to contacting me. This ensures that you are able to decide in advance what you want and how I can best serve you. Please note that not every order request can be accepted during high-volume seasons.
A Guide to All Things Carrot Cake

This month on ‘For Goodness Bakes', we'll be talking all things carrot cake: the do's, the don’ts, and the secrets to getting it right every time.

Read More  
Baking at High Altitude: The Baker's Battle

For Goodness Bakes! The formidable foe of baking above sea level can be conquered by utlizing kitchen science and a few easy recipe adjustments....

Read More  

Want exclusive access to discounts, news, AND 15% off your first order?

How about a special treat for your birthday? Then sign up for my email list today!

Stay up to date with everything That Cake Lady of Santa Fe has to offer. Just send me a message with your name, email, and birthday, and get instant access to exclusive discounts and content as soon as they're available.

I BUILT MY SITE FOR FREE USING